Humble and Generous Gifts

  • cage1052
    Master
    Insider

    I have some questions about the "Charitable Giving for All" and "Bountiful Giving for All" commendations:

    1. If I leave a humble or generous gift at the Reaper's Hideout or at an outpost, and then sign off. When another crew turns it in... does it count towards the commendation for me and my crew?
    2. If I give a gift to another crew, and then we have a server merge and end up on different servers, will it count towards the commendation for me and my crew when they turn it in?
    3. If I give a gift to another crew, and then sign off. Will it count towards the commendations for me and my crew when they turn it in?

    Thanks for the answers - I am trying to work towards completing many commendations, and these are a bit ambiguous in the in-game description, so I appreciate some clarity.

  • Login To Reply
    6
    Posts
    7.7k
    Views
  • D3ADST1CK
    Vanguard
    Insider
    Founder

    @cage1052 said in Humble and Generous Gifts:

    I have some questions about the "Charitable Giving for All" and "Bountiful Giving for All" commendations:

    1. If I leave a humble or generous gift at the Reaper's Hideout or at an outpost, and then sign off. When another crew turns it in... does it count towards the commendation for me and my crew?
    2. If I give a gift to another crew, and then we have a server merge and end up on different servers, will it count towards the commendation for me and my crew when they turn it in?
    3. If I give a gift to another crew, and then sign off. Will it count towards the commendations for me and my crew when they turn it in?

    Thanks for the answers - I am trying to work towards completing many commendations, and these are a bit ambiguous in the in-game description, so I appreciate some clarity.

    You need to be in game in order for anything to count. I think server merges will wipe your information from the gift and it won't count, but I can't be certain.

  • PithyRumble
    Rogue
    Insider

    90% sure you still need to be logged in to get credit for gifts.

  • TheTwistedTaste
    Lord
    Insider

    @cage1052 said in Humble and Generous Gifts:

    1. If I leave a humble or generous gift at the Reaper's Hideout or at an outpost, and then sign off. When another crew turns it in... does it count towards the commendation for me and my crew?

    No.

    1. If I give a gift to another crew, and then we have a server merge and end up on different servers, will it count towards the commendation for me and my crew when they turn it in?

    No.

    1. If I give a gift to another crew, and then sign off. Will it count towards the commendations for me and my crew when they turn it in?

    No.

    The only guaranteed way to tick up the commendation is by staying in the current server you’re playing on.

    While I do not have 100% clarity on the exact facts, I have “been there and done that” for every possible theory as I myself still haven’t completed the giving commendations over the last 3 years.

    Trivia: Gifts also do not count if you bury them, post to the map board, and have another crew unbury and sell them (whether still in the server, or having left)

    Hope this helps!

  • cage1052
    Master
    Insider

    Thanks, everyone - I assumed that none of those would count, but thought I'd ask.

    One last question -

    If I steal a gift from another crew, and then give it to a 3rd crew, does my crew or the first crew get the credit towards the commendation?

  • TheTwistedTaste
    Lord
    Insider

    @cage1052 said in Humble and Generous Gifts:

    One last question -

    If I steal a gift from another crew, and then give it to a 3rd crew, does my crew or the first crew get the credit towards the commendation?

    Hmm 🤔

    I think the first crew (if they’re still on the server) gets the credit. I believe loot only remembers the first player that touches it, not the most recent, or stolen loot wouldn’t work (as you’d be the last to touch it and therefore not “stolen”)

Login To Reply
6
Posts
7.7k
Views
1 out of 6