Possible decipher/clues

  • DutchDeadSchot
    Master
    Insider
    Founder

    @mad-jack-ketch aye.. what be in the distance fellow cap’n?

  • Mad Jack Ketch
    Lord
    Insider
    Boatswain
    Founder

    All will be revealed soon :)

  • Suave Beard
    Founder

    There is an uncharted island not being mentioned in this thread that has some interesting content on it and under it.

    Although having spent a few hours on it I can't say I feel it has much to do with the secret tavern, unless it is part of a puzzle, and the rest is elsewhere.

  • McDoll
    Castaway
    Insider
    Founder

    @suave-beard I feel as though I know the island of which you speak.
    I'd describe it as an atoll or reef.
    Certainly more interesting UNDER than atop it.

  • Straw Hat Blake
    Master
    Insider

    @mad-jack-ketch there is an uncharted island with a hidden cave in the center of the map close to where that circle is. If you see the crossword puzzle as a big map. And with 26 letters in the alphabet 13 is dead center for everything!

  • Straw Hat Blake
    Master
    Insider

    @racmop where can you see the ferryman in the water?

  • Mad Jack Ketch
    Lord
    Insider
    Boatswain
    Founder

    @suave-beard the reef you are on about has the empty cave when you swim under? If so that’s really not helping with the hideout as such :)

  • Mad Jack Ketch
    Lord
    Insider
    Boatswain
    Founder

    Whom said the waterfall was actually visible? What if the waterfall is in a cave or what if the hideout isn't on an island but huge rocks?

    alt text

  • Mad Jack Ketch
    Lord
    Insider
    Boatswain
    Founder

    No Lemons Atoll and now this...? alt text

  • M4ST3RofSQWANCH
    Founder

    @mad-jack-ketch the Bermuda triangle?

  • Mad Jack Ketch
    Lord
    Insider
    Boatswain
    Founder

    @brozplaygamez For the hideout, i'm thinking you gotta swim through a cave or something similar as the "Door" to the hideout isn't open yet.

  • M4ST3RofSQWANCH
    Founder

    @mad-jack-ketch honestly I think someone needs to just call up James Cameron n get his sub to explore the depth of the SoT ocean. Can someone mod him into the game? We may even find cameronium...

    Seriously though I like your sleuthing. When the full game hits it'll be easier to figure out. Until then we can only speculate and accumulate.

  • P B JamyTime
    Master
    Insider

    Pirates and sailors were able to cure scurvy by ingesting fresh lemons/juice. Could “No Lemons”=Scurvy Isles? The Black Sand “Atoll” is slightly NE of it, with Old Faithful lying between. They share the same region, “The Wilds”...just a thought...

  • P B JamyTime
    Master
    Insider

    Just saw another thread on this same topic with others theorizing hours ago what I said. Haha! Maybe we should combine the two posts? You know, have one place to go with a complete list of our ideas. It’d be a much more thorough process imo.

  • Mad Jack Ketch
    Lord
    Insider
    Boatswain
    Founder

    So after playing yesterday, I am convinced;

    A. Hidden hideout isn't in this version
    B. It's hidden in a rock and not an island

  • Straw Hat Blake
    Master
    Insider

    @racmop where did you swim down to see the ferryman?

Login To Reply
51
Posts
31.1k
Views
45 out of 51