@rk1-turbulence said in The Castaway King!:
Honestly, I'd rather have it the other way around. My voyages are all captain's and marauder's, with a seafarer's once in a while. Castaway's chests are the rarest chests in the game!
This idea would actually work well for all the loot types, but you already get good money for the higher tier items.
The Castaway King obviously lives like a Castaway, coveting his precious, broken chests and calling them by pet names. If you show up without a castaway chest, he might actually shoot you!
Then there's Shipwreck Sam who you can find floating in a dingy far out to sea. He gives you double your money for any chest with barnacles and seaweed on it.
Black Betty on the other hand is searching for her cursed and murdered love, and will give you as much as triple price for Foul skulls.
Once you find any of them, they do the transaction and move along, which is what encourages the hoarding. You never know where or when you'll find them again, but you better have your goods when you do.