It seems there are three main ways of doing voyages.
Option 1: Select a voyage, and check it for what kind of loot it offers. For example, 4-5+ chests on a single island for Gold Hoarders. 4 skulls on a island for Order of Souls. or 1-2 gold animals for Merchant Alliance. If the quest has one of these, you go out, collect it and then cancel the voyage to start another looking for the same requirements.
Option 2: You search for the same criteria as above, but instead of cancelling after collecting the "main haul", you complete the entire voyage.
Option 3: Complete all voyages, no matter what loot they offer.
So in terms of Reputation / Experience, what do you feel is the best option? How about in terms of getting the most gold?
Thanks all!